Schengen visa refusal reason 10 explained: "information submitted was not reliable"
Reason 10 is not "your documents were missing". It is "your documents were there and we did not believe them". That distinction decides the repair.
The text
Ground 10 on the Annex VI refusal form reads, verbatim: "the information submitted regarding the justification for the purpose and conditions of the intended stay was not reliable". Its legal parent is Article 32(1)(b) of the Visa Code, which requires refusal where "there are reasonable doubts as to the authenticity of the supporting documents submitted by the applicant or the veracity of their contents, the reliability of the statements made by the applicant or his intention to leave the territory of the Member States before the expiry of the visa applied for".
What triggers it in practice
Ground 10 is ticked when the purpose-of-stay evidence exists but does not convince. Typical patterns:
- Hotel and flight bookings that look made to be cancelled (free-cancellation reservations for every night, or reservations that were already cancelled when the consulate checked).
- An itinerary that no one would follow: five countries in seven days, or overnight jumps that ignore geography.
- An invitation letter the consulate could not verify by phone or that contradicts the applicant's stated relationship.
- A cover letter that describes a different trip from the bookings, or copies a template so closely that it reads as generic.
- A business trip with no meeting agenda, no counterpart letter, or a counterpart who cannot be reached.
Reason 10 versus reason 13
Reason 13 ("reasonable doubts as to your intention to leave") is about you: your anchors to India. Reason 10 is about the trip: whether it is real. A file can fail either alone or both together, and consulates often tick both. If only 10 is ticked, your ties were accepted; the repair is entirely on the trip side. If both, rebuild both.
The repair
- Build the itinerary first, then the bookings, then the letter, and make them agree to the day and the city.
- Prefer bookings you can hold through the decision. Refundable is fine; visibly cancelled is not.
- Give the consulate things it can check: a hotel it can call, an inviter with a landline and an address, an employer letter with a name that will answer.
- Write a cover letter that is specific to this trip: dates, cities, who you are seeing, what you are paying, why now. Cut every generic sentence.
- If the trip is to visit family or friends, prove the relationship (photos are weak; residence permits, prior visits, and a properly witnessed invitation form where the state uses one are strong).
After a reason-10 refusal
An appeal succeeds only if you can show the consulate misread evidence that was in the file. Because reason 10 is a judgment call on the file's credibility, most applicants do better with a rebuilt application than an appeal. The refusal is recorded in the VIS (Article 32(5)), so the second file will be read against the first; it must be visibly stronger on the exact point that failed.
FAQ
Is reason 10 the same as reason 2?
No. Ground 2 says justification "was not provided" (missing). Ground 10 says what was provided "was not reliable" (present but not believed). The repair for 2 is completeness; for 10 it is credibility.
Can I appeal a reason-10 refusal?
Yes, under Article 32(3), through the deciding state's national procedure stated on your form. Whether it is worth it depends on whether the consulate overlooked evidence you actually submitted.
Questions this page answers
Is reason 10 the same as reason 2?
No. Ground 2 says justification "was not provided" (missing). Ground 10 says what was provided "was not reliable" (present but not believed). The repair for 2 is completeness; for 10 it is credibility.
Can I appeal a reason-10 refusal?
Yes, under Article 32(3), through the deciding state's national procedure stated on your form. Whether it is worth it depends on whether the consulate overlooked evidence you actually submitted.